Business, Unity Flash is dead in March – Unity3d coming to Windows

14 Comments

(Yes, the titillating title of this post is meant to incite passion to get your attention. Please continue reading.)

I mentioned a little bit ago that Unity3d is releasing the authoring IDE for Windows with version 2.5. I read in the forums that they would release 2.5 no later than GDC, which is in March.

avert-fate-unity Unity is tempting me to completely ditch Flash. But there’s one factor making that a bad decision for the moment. Although I think eventually I will make games in Unity exclusively (assuming it all works out as dreamily as it seems like it will), Flash can’t be abandoned yet.

What’s so great about Flash?

Adoption. Everyone and their granny’s dairy goat has Flash installed. Adoption by itself, though, isn’t what makes adoption so great. Its really about…

…distribution. I can get a game in front of hundreds of thousands of eyeballs in a week using Flash. A lot of folks would think, “Gee, maybe you could make a few hundred dollars from ads. That’s not so great. Jason is stupid, and I hate him.” And then they’d go back and continue working on their C++ downloadable game. But I beg to differ.

It’s not about the ad money. It’s the traffic, ya silly persons! Why would I care about a few hundred dollars of ad money when I can get ten thousand visitors to my website each week or month? And I don’t mean putting Google ads on the site and earning from that, either. No, no, no. That’s still small potatoes.

I’m talking about harnessing the traffic machine that is Flash games and then upselling to those visitors with bigger ticket items, like stand alone games or (much more likely in my case) getting them interested in games that utilize microtransactions and/or subscription services. Now you’re talking about significant income.

Make money with ads? Pfft! I use MochiAds because I like their version control, easy encryption and especially their distribution network that sends games out to millions of people for me!

There are some other neat things about Flash, but the real reason I use it is because of distribution and other services that have risen up around it.

There’s this cool idea of sponsorship, where developers are in control, and portals pay us to show their ad to drive traffic back to them. (Did anyone notice these portals are driving traffic back to their sites? See! It’s about traffic, not ad money!)

The thing I like about this sponsorship arrangement is that it is in diametric opposition to how things work with portals that sell downloadable games. There, developers are like slaves who beg for any tiny piece of profit their own work can earn. Portals call the shots, make the money, and generally drive the industry into the ground to the point that now it’s going to be flailing around and coughing up blood for a long time until (hopefully) it finally dies some day. It’s just like the retail games business, where publishers lead developers around by the nose, take all the earnings, and drive the whole industry into the ground in the process.

(I have a lot of friends in the downloadable casual games industry, and I’m not speaking here about anyone in particular. I’m speaking about the industry and the patterns of business that are currently dominant. I certainly don’t mean that I want my casual games friends to lose their jobs! I just think that industry needs to and will evolve away from how it currently operates.)

Wow. Sorry, I was digressing passionately there for a minute.

So now here comes Unity.

Unity lacks that distribution power, and although technically it is a dream come true, the real dream come true is when that technical capability is coupled with distribution and reach on par with Flash. Now that is going to be a sight to see.

hero-master I hope that existing portals and services based around Flash will integrate Unity support. Then we can keep the existing structures in place and add Unity games among the Flash games. Oh, let me dream, would ya?!

Now. All that having been said… I am not convinced that adoption itself is a problem for Unity. I think any game that’s good enough will cause players to install the Unity plugin without hesitation. I don’t mean something like a Simon Says clone or some other shovelware game made in three days–it’ll have to be a good game.

Because of Unity’s appeal, which will make convincing players to get the plugin easy, I will start to develop with Unity as soon as I get my shaking-with-excitement hands on a copy. Building more games can only mean more adoption and, eventually, more distribution. Distribution = earnings = I make more games without a day job. Yuussssss!!1!

14 Responses to “Flash is dead in March – Unity3d coming to Windows”

  1. Lucas Meijer Says:

    Nice post!

    For more thoughts on the importance of unity web player penetration see:

    http://lucasmeijer.com/posts/more-director-vs-unity/

    and

    http://blogs.unity3d.com/2008/03/31/thoughts-on-browser-plugin-penetration/

    Bye, Lucas

  2. Fyorl Says:

    I much prefer Flash over Unity because I can actually play Flash games on my Linux computer. Unity has kindly completely ignored the Linux community. I lose a lot of respect for games developers who like to ignore whole communities which is why Bioware are my favourite developers. They actually made Neverwinter Nights with both DirectX and OpenGL support so Linux users could play it pretty much out-of-the-box. The extra effort they went to for that barely made much difference to earnings since the Linux community is small but it just shows what an awesome company they are.

  3. Zeitalter3 Entwicklerblog » Blog Archiv » Kurz gebloggt: Teufelskreise, Fonts, 3d und 2d Says:

    [...] kommt. Die Frage ist: sollten wir es Flash vorziehen? Jason von Creatix hat da seine eigene Meinung zu. So oder so, ich denke Flash wird sich mehr ins Zeug legen müssen – die Konkurrenz ist [...]

  4. Michael Sharpe Says:

    looks great but sadly, no linux so i won’t be using it.

    Haven’t several other “things” tried to break flash/replace it before? Microsoft silverlight not doing it for you?

  5. Dan Taylor Says:

    Great article Jason! Agreed on the massive and widespread distribution of Flash, as it’s a primary element to many web features that we use on a daily basis (think the rise of YouTube).

    Echoing Fyrol’s statements above – not such a great move cutting out the entire Linux community. Hopefully these pleas will fall upon the right ears.

  6. jason Says:

    It’s unofficial and may never get anywhere (disclaimer stated from the forums), but http://tirania.org/blog/archive/2008/Nov-14.html might be interesting for Linux users.

  7. TOPBUSINESSIDEAS Says:

    I hope you make that killer app, jason!

  8. diamondTearz » Blog Archive » Unity3D vs Flash Or Not- Blogosphere Roundup Says:

    [...] Flash is Dead in March Unity3D Coming to Windows- Written 1/25/09 added 2/25/09 Related Posts:Unity3D Resources Collection- The MotherLoad Has Landed!!More Unity Goodness13 Reasons for Flash Developers to Learn Unity 3DUnity3D 2.5- Go Ahead Rub Your Eyes…on Windows-Vista Too!!A Weekend with Unity3D- I feel like I cheated on Flash! Share and Enjoy: [...]

  9. Marco Says:

    Hello! You might be interested in my solution to integrate Flash and Unity, please check out this demonstration:

    http://gamelix.com/demos/flashcot/flashcot_background.html

    If you want more information please visit my website: http://gamelix.com/?page_id=31

    Regards!
    -Marco

  10. dcfree Says:

    Great article. Absolutely agree. Flash ain’t dead yet by a long shot, but w/o addressing 3d seriously, I have to believe it’s days are numbered. Interesting days ahead.
    -dcfree

  11. How We Met- Love at First Site with Unity 3D Viloating Jay-Z’s rules with Unity3D diamondTearz’s Flex, Flash, iPhone & Unity3D Blog Says:

    [...] compares to your old flame. You had already told them that come march when Unity is on Windows that Flash is Dead to you Family members are getting to know her and getting in touch with members of her family. [...]

  12. Unity vs Flash or not -Blogosphere Roundup – Version 2 Says:

    [...] Flash is Dead in March Unity Coming to Windows- Written 1/25/09 added 2/25/09 [...]

  13. Unity vs Flash or not -Blogosphere Roundup Says:

    [...] Flash is Dead in March Unity Coming to Windows- Written 1/25/09 added 2/25/09 [...]

  14. Unity3D Resource Lists Says:

    [...] Flash is Dead in March-Unity3D Coming to Windows [...]

Leave a Reply