Game Geek Speak

The microtransaction bug seems to be going viral these days among the Flash community. There are a growing number of companies offering managed payment services to Flash developers: they handle the dirty backside, and you give them content and share the income.

I personally think that it is worth it to build your own system (and I’m usually the guy saying, “Use the middleware, fool!”). But I think it depends on the scale of what you are planning. In my case, I want total control, and I want to own access to my customers so that I can continue to communicate with them. I also don’t want my games to become advertisements for a payment service.

I don’t view virtual item sales as just a sales channel. It’s also a gesture that means a player cares about and is emotionally invested in the game, and I want to maximize that relationship to make my players happy, long-term customers. Without access to my customers, the payment service is crippling my business. I don’t know that all these systems insulate the developer from his/her customers, but that is a major issue to bear in mind.

These Flash-specific services could be really useful to someone who is making much smaller scale games and wants some add-on sales or someone experimenting with virtual goods in an effort to diminish reliance on ad revenue. I’m not reviewing any of the services, just announcing that they exist. I haven’t investigated them all very deeply, but I will be poking around.

75% – andrograde.com
70% – www.nonoba.com
60% – www.gamersafe.com
60% – www.mochimedia.com
50% – www.heyzap.com

Which is best? It depends on your goals and plans. If you’re just making little quickie games (90% of Flash games), then any of the above would work. If you have a more broadly scoped business plan, you might want to steer clear and look into services that are not Flash-specific and spend the time/money to do the integration yourself.